Match.com

Wrestler Date Location Notes
 D. Lo Brown January 5, 1996 Fort Wright, KY Defeated Bobby Blaze in Tournament Final
Bobby Blaze March 9, 1996 Ashland, KY  
D. Lo Brown (2) March 16, 1996 Lima, OH Title became inactive from June 1996 to May 2000
Race Steele May 25, 2000 Cincinnati, OH Defeated Chip Fairway in Tournament Final
Chad Collyer January 26, 2001 Rising Sun, IN Stripped of the title
Shark Boy February 27, 2001 Cincinnati, OH Defeated Matt Stryker & Dean Jablonski in Tournament Final
Race Steele (2) March 16, 2001 Rising Sun, IN  
Cody Hawk July 7, 2001 Cincinnati, OH  
Race Steele (3) August 4, 2001 Batavia, OH  
Nick Dinsmore August 9, 2001 Cincinnati, OH  
Race Steele (4) August 18, 2001 Dayton, OH Title held up on Sept 30, 2001
EZ Money November 14, 2001 Dayton, OH Defeated D. Lo Brown in Tournament Final
Charlie Haas January 9, 2002 Dayton, OH Stripped of title on Jan 29, 2002
EZ Money (2) January 29, 2002 Dayton, OH Awarded title
Rico Constantino March 15, 2002 Dayton, OH  
Stevie Richards March 17, 2002 Jeffersonville, IN  
Race Steele (5) March 20, 2002 Cincinnati, OH  
Johnny The Bull May 8, 2002 Dayton, OH  
Lance Cade May 19, 2002 Jeffersonville, IN  
Johnny The Bull (2) July 20, 2002 Batavia, OH  
Lance Cade (2) July 20, 2002 Batavia, OH  
Cody Hawk (2) July 21, 2002 Jeffersonville, IN  
Matt Stryker September 17, 2002 Cincinnati, OH  
Chet Jablonski November 9, 2002 Batavia, OH  
Matt Stryker (2) January 3, 2003 Batavia, OH  
Cody Hawk (3) March 24, 2003 Wilmington, OH  
Matt Stryker (3) March 29, 2003 Wilmington, OH  
Ala Hussein April 15, 2003 Cincinnati, OH  
Chad Collyer (2) May 2, 2003 Aurora, IN  
Nigel McGuinness September 6, 2003 Batavia, OH  
Hoss January 3, 2004 Batavia, OH  
Nigel McGuinness (2) January 6, 2004 Cincinnati, OH  
El Temor March 17, 2004 Cincinnati, OH  
Rory Fox March 30, 2004 Cincinnati, OH  
Shawn Osborne March 25, 2005 Dayton, OH  
Matt Stryker (4) June 17, 2005 Cincinnati, OH  
Cody Hawk (4) September 23, 2005 Cincinnati, OH Stripped of the title in Nov 2005
Pepper Parks January 3, 2006 Cincinnati, OH Defeated Jon Moxley in Tournament Final
Jon Moxley May 9, 2006 Cincinnati, OH  
Chad Collyer (2) September 12, 2006 Cincinnati, OH  
Pepper Parks (2) November 7, 2006 Cincinnati, OH

Pepper vacates the title on Dec 5, 2006

Jon Moxley (2) December 30, 2006 Dayton, OH Won Fatal 4 Way to win vacant title
Buffalo Bad Boy January 2, 2007 Cincinnati, OH  
BJ Whitmer January 18, 2008 Dayton, OH Stripped of the title on June 11, 2008
Jake Crist July 11, 2008 Cincinnati, OH Defeated Jon Moxley  in playoff match
King Vu August 22, 2009 Norwood, OH  
Aaron Williams December 19, 2009 Norwood, OH
Jon Moxley (3) January 6, 2010 Middletown, OH